I’ve been guilty of it myself. You pull up to a juicy run that’s usually elbow-to-elbow, but this time you have it all to yourself. You rig up, run down the trail, run back up because you forgot to lock your truck, run down the trail again—and then cast to the same two fish for the next couple of hours. This spot is always taken, so of course you want to get the most out of it. The fish will turn on; you just need to give them time. Or do you?
The Problem With Staying Still
Fish are constantly moving targets. Trout are always roaming the river in search of food, protection, and oxygen-rich water. Sometimes they get pushed out by larger fish, or maybe the current shifts and they tuck behind a rock for softer flow. They might move off a shelf and toward the bank in search of a clumsy evening mouse. They’ll also slide out or go down when spooked by a splashing angler.
The point is simple: trout are living, breathing creatures in constant motion because their environment is always changing. Think about it this way—do you stay in one spot all day? I personally don’t eat, use the bathroom, drop off the mail, and walk the dog all from my couch.
Steelhead take this concept to the next level. These migratory fish may hold in the same pool all day—or they might cover three full river miles daily during their upstream push to spawning grounds. A steelhead angler who camps on the same run (which may only hold a single fish at any given time) is setting himself up for disappointment. Not all steelhead are willing to take a fly, so it only makes sense to put one in front of as many fish as possible until you find that aggressive grab.
The Efficient Angler
Staying mobile is the single best way to put more fish on the reel—trout and steelhead alike. My number-one rule is to cover as much water as possible. If a trout doesn’t eat your fly within a couple of casts, it doesn’t want it. Move on. Fish that rock honestly, but don’t linger if the fish isn’t a player. It pays to seek out the ones that are willing.
The efficient angler adapts to changing conditions and becomes wiser by fishing more water. Steelheading on the Deschutes is a great example. In the morning, skinny tailouts are prime for a skated or dry fly—no better time to find a steelhead willing to rise. I cover this water quickly since a player will usually reveal itself right away. If a fish rises but doesn’t commit to the dry, I’ll quickly swap to a wet fly and make the same cast. As the sun creeps over the canyon walls, steelhead become wary in the glare. Before it gets too hot, I’ll fish a sink-tip through the deeper slots where they’re less light-shy. And when the canyon bakes in the afternoon? That’s nap time.
Efficiency also means pacing yourself correctly. Take the Boat Pool on the North Umpqua River—one of the finest steelhead runs you’ll ever fish. The Boat always holds fish. Summer steelhead will rise to a dry and move several feet from their lie to eat. That means I can cover ground fast: cast, swing, take two generous steps, and repeat. Winter fish are a different story. In turbid water, they’ll only eat when the fly swings within a foot or so of their face. That demands sink tips and smaller steps—sometimes just one per cast. Their behavior dictates the pace.
When It Makes Sense to Stay Put
There are times when it’s smart to work a spot hard. If trout are actively rising to a thick hatch, cast until your arm is sore. The fish aren’t shy, the bugs are abundant, and you’ve got plenty of targets.
It also makes sense to slow down when a run has a lot of structure, as long as you can fish it effectively. Staying put doesn’t mean standing still—change your angles, wade to new positions, fish the opposite bank, and cover every side of that midstream boulder.
Even when you linger, vary your tactics. Start with dries, then switch to emergers or nymphs. After nymphing, try a streamer to tempt an aggressive eater. Staying put shouldn’t mean staying stagnant.
And in winter, patience really does pay. Cold water makes trout conserve energy, feeding lazily in troughs, slots, and ledges. Slow down, make efficient casts, and move on only after you’ve fished the water thoroughly and honestly.
The Bottom Line
The angler who keeps moving is the angler who fishes efficiently. Casting again and again to the same disinterested or spooked fish is wasted effort. Covering water increases your odds of finding players—fish that are actually willing to eat. Not every piece of water will produce every day. Conditions change. Fish move. It’s our job to adapt and keep searching.
And if you don’t find players? Well, a day on the river is still good for the soul.
-T
Leave a comment